声誉之争 一触即发 Ethos 与 Web3 的声誉战争走到了哪里？机会在哪里？近期Ethos的版本升级有哪些？一文带你窥探一二，建议转发收藏（说在版本升级时） 昨晚 @serpinxbt Ethos各圈层的活跃参与者，围绕 Udi 的声誉争议展开了公开讨论。我全程听了，这不仅是对某个项目或人物的舆论检验，更是一场关于“共识”是否真实、“声誉”是否可度量的集体沉思。 这是一次现实主义的对话，也是一场共识系统的照妖镜。 @ethos_network 一、让我们回顾下Ethos是什么？ Ethos 是一个记录「链上声誉」的协议，目标是搭建一个可处理、可查询、可共识的“链上人物声誉图谱”。 ● 用户可以对一个项目/一个人进行明确的价值判断：是否值得信任？是否选择支持？ ● 所有操作都有链上纪录，成为声誉分数的组成部分 ● 此分数并不直接影响价格，但有可能影响到 DAO 治理中的值得信任程度 它的本质：链上共识的可视化系统。 ✐.ɴɪᴄᴇ ᴅᴀʏ ・ ・ ・ 二、Space 讨论了什么？ 讨论热点是 Udi 在社群中声誉下滚。有用户对他发起 slash （减信操作），引发大量旧伙伴和社群战队参与评分，其中包括 skull NFT 社群。 讨论分类： ● 声誉是情绪之和？还是理性衡量？ ● Ethos 是在重现其真，还是在放大偏见？ ● Web3 是否能存在真正的「重叠性共识」？ Adam McBride @adamamcbride 提醒： 我支持 Leonidas，不意味着我必须反对 Udi。声誉不是静态判决，而是实际行为的结果。 Serpin 则提醒： 我们不是判决者，我们只是声誉共识的纪录者。 ✐.ɴɪᴄᴇ ᴅᴀʏ ・ ・ ・ 三、Ethos 是 SocialFi、InfoFi，还是别的什么？ 这场 Space 也触发了一个机制层的讨论——Ethos 属于哪个协议类型？ ➹ 它不是 SocialFi，因为它不以“社交关系”为主干，也没有围绕“关系变现”设计。 ➹ 它也不完全是 InfoFi，因为它并不直接金融化信息传播价值。 ➹ 它更像是 ReputationFi（声誉金融），甚至可以说是一个早期形态的 ConsensusFi（共识金融）。 为什么是 ReputationFi？ 因为 Ethos 关注的不是信息本身，而是“信息对身份的影响”——你是谁，别人怎么看你，你的声誉如何随时间和事件起伏，这些都会影响你是否能加入某个DAO、是否能成为某个社区的代表性人物。 它测量的，是你的“链上信任体温”。 ✐.ɴɪᴄᴇ ᴅᴀʏ ・ ・ ・ 四、这件事的症结：共识是否可信？ 讨论声誉机制时，有一个不可忽视的悖论： ✔ Web3 鼓吹“共识驱动”，但每个“共识”都是带情绪的； ✔Ethos 想提供一个共识观察器，但很多时候它捕捉到的，其实是“部落标签 + bag bias + 愤怒动员”。 在这次 Udi 的事件中，slash 行为中出现大量来自某 NFT 项目（skull）用户，这意味着评分并不一定是“独立判断”，而可能是社群动员下的集体表态行为。 这时我们就必须问一个问题： 声誉评分真的代表“共识”？还是只是“社交武器”？(所以我一直很烦抱团和搞小团体，这将让事情变得很不公平和不透明) ✐.ɴɪᴄᴇ ᴅᴀʏ ・ ・ ・ 五、没有人不在共识风暴中 今天是 Udi，明天可能是你我。 在没有链上身份合一机制的今天，每一个地址其实都是“动态评价体”——你做了一件事、说了一句话、支持了某个项目、得罪了某个社区，你的声誉就会被打分。 这并不意味着 Ethos 的机制不好，反而说明它是一个极具实验价值的“去中心化舆情观察器”。 但我们必须知道： ツ 共识本身是模糊的，不是裁决 ツ 声誉不是静态的，是事件驱动的流动标签 ツ 被投票，不等于被定义 毛毛结语： Ethos 是首次让我们看见，“声誉” 是可视化的；“共识” 是可被分析的。 但同时，它也揭露了 Web3 真相的一面： 更快速地分发标签，更可视化地曝光偏见，更不容易被原谅。 这并非坏事，而是一种现实。加入 Web3 前，你需要先明白的，是没有任何声誉是不受其他人影响的 没有任何人能完全逃脱社群意识的进攻 Serpin说的话，我们可能需要记住： 我们不是在预测谁会冷，我们只是在记录——共识正在发生改变。 最后才是你们关心的最新版本存在什么机会，恭喜你耐心看完 ◄ ◅ ◆ ◇ ◈ ◉ ◊ ○ ◌ ◍ ◎ ● Ethos Season I 快来了，以下是正式启动前瞻 关键词：行为信号、声誉资产、贡献量化 Ethos 正在进入一个更加系统化、可追踪的声誉周期：Season I，这将是 Web3 社群如何“共识打分、信任映射、身份金融化”的一次深度试验。 以下是本轮 Season I 重点计分项与行为激励机制整理： 🎯 1. 贡献内容质量（Quality） “你所写的每一条评语、评论、支持（vouch）或削减（slash），其内容质量，是最重要的声誉资产。” 意义：鼓励非机械化内容、避免敷衍打分 实际效果：高质量内容将优先计入声誉模型与排名计算 🤝 2. 信任支持（Vouching） “你为他人投出的 ETH 支持额度，是你对信任的公开标记。被互相支持（reciprocated）者优先加权。” 意义：形成基于资金支持的信任图谱 激励：互相 vouch 会被系统视为更强“声誉连接” 💠 3. http://Ethos.markets 持仓行为 “你持有的信任/不信任投票仓位，是一种带风险的投机性共识行为。” 类似“链上市场版信任预测市场” 风险越高，表示共识强度越大，对网络的贡献度越高 🎟️ 4. 验证者 NFT（Validator NFTs） “连接至 Ethos 账户的钱包中持有 Validator NFT，可叠加声誉加权。” 提供“身份验证”与“系统偏好”的双重信号 未来可能作为高级功能或治理权的门槛凭证 🩸 5. Slash 行为参与 “发起、参与或投票 slash 提案，皆可记录为共识信号，质量为首。” 重点：不是“数量”，而是“精准度”+“参与理据” 有利于成为“共识校正型用户” 📆 6. 每日活跃打卡（Daily Streaks） “持续签到并提供实时信息更新，是你作为网络贡献者持续参与的证明。” 形成“声誉时间线” 可用于衡量用户“共识行为的连续性” 📲 7. X 平台验证任务（Ethos Agent Validations） “通过标注 @ethosAgent validate 的方式，验证 Twitter 上的讨论内容或行为是否真实。” 建立从 Web2 到 Web3 的行为桥梁 积分排行榜展示在：http://validate.ethos.network 此处感谢 @__MLO_ 的英文版本的分享 🆕 Ethos 新功能更新速览（2025.6 最新上线） 1️⃣ 本地化情绪分析：Local Sentiment Analysis 👯‍♂️ “现在，已登录用户将看到来自你认识或信任的人的共识情绪。” 🔍 解读： 不再是全网平均得分，而是强调**“你的社群视角”**； 优先呈现你互相关注、互动、vouch过的人对某项目/人物的看法； 是一种去中心化社交图谱下的“信任过滤器”。 📌 实际意义： 更少被陌生人操控舆论； 共识判断更精准、符合社群语境； 非常适合 DAO 内部治理、团体共识共建、项目声誉管理。 2️⃣ 排行榜细节更新：Leaderboard Position + Unique Identity Highlights 🏆 “你现在可以在每个排行榜上看到自己的位置，以及你在项目或社群中的独特贡献标签。” 🔖 解读： 每个用户现在都可以看到自己在“贡献者榜 / 信任榜 / slash榜”上的排名； 还会自动展示你的代表性标签（如：early slasher、top vouch node、validator、daily streak leader 等）； 🚀 带来的价值： 明确的身份反馈机制； 打造「链上声誉档案」的关键一步； 对 DAO、社群治理、公平激励机制非常有帮助。 刚刚在群里看到消息说Infofi 龙头 @KaitoAI 也要开始加入声誉积分系统了，大战一触即发！不知道 @ethos_network 面对龙头下场能不能扛住压力，打造自己无可代替的产品出来。 我们慢慢看，未完待续.... 以下是英文 ⚔️ The Reputation War Is About to Erupt Where is Ethos in the Web3 reputation battlefield? Where are the real opportunities? What updates are included in the latest version of Ethos? This article offers a curated deep dive—worth a read and a share (especially as new updates roll out). Last night, @serpinxbt and a broad mix of active Ethos participants across different circles gathered for a public Twitter Space to discuss the reputation controversy surrounding Udi. I listened in from beginning to end. What unfolded was more than just public scrutiny of a person or project—it became a collective meditation on whether "consensus" is real and whether "reputation" can be measured. It was a realist conversation, and at the same time, a mirror exposing the mechanics of consensus. @ethos_network 1. What Is Ethos? Ethos is a protocol designed to record on-chain reputation, with the goal of building a consensus-ready, queryable, and structured reputation graph of individuals in Web3. Users can issue clear judgments: Is this person/project trustworthy? Worth supporting? Every action is recorded on-chain and contributes to the user’s reputation score. While the score doesn’t directly affect token prices, it may influence trustworthiness in DAO governance. In essence: A visualization system for on-chain consensus. 2. What Was Discussed in the Space? The hot topic was Udi’s plummeting reputation in the community. Some users initiated a slash (downgrade action), prompting a wave of scoring activity, including from groups like the Skull NFT community. Key questions raised: Is reputation just an accumulation of emotions? Or a rational metric? Is Ethos uncovering the truth—or magnifying biases? Can Web3 ever achieve true overlapping consensus? Adam McBride (@adamamcbride) reminded everyone: “Supporting Leonidas doesn’t mean I must oppose Udi. Reputation is not a static verdict—it’s a result of behavior.” Serpin added: “We are not the judges—we are just the recorders of consensus.” 3. Is Ethos SocialFi, InfoFi—or Something Else? This discussion sparked a deeper question: What kind of protocol is Ethos? It’s not SocialFi—Ethos isn’t built on monetizing social relationships. It’s not purely InfoFi—it doesn’t directly financialize information value. It’s more aligned with ReputationFi, or even an early prototype of ConsensusFi. Why ReputationFi? Because Ethos isn’t about information itself—it’s about how information shapes identity. Who you are, how others perceive you, and how your reputation evolves over time all influence whether you can enter a DAO or become a leading figure in a community. Ethos is measuring your “on-chain trust temperature.” 4. The Core Dilemma: Is Consensus Trustworthy? There’s a paradox at the heart of reputation systems: ✔ Web3 promotes consensus-driven governance, but every consensus is emotionally charged. ✔ Ethos wants to be a consensus observer—but it often ends up recording tribal labels + bag bias + rage mobs. In Udi’s case, many slash votes came from one NFT community (Skull), suggesting the scoring wasn’t purely based on independent judgment—it may have been collective signaling mobilized by group dynamics. Which begs the question: Is a reputation score truly a reflection of consensus—or just a social weapon? (This is exactly why I dislike cliques—they distort fairness and transparency.) 5. No One Is Safe from the Consensus Storm Today it's Udi—tomorrow, it could be you or me. Without a unified on-chain identity system, every wallet is a dynamic evaluation entity. One action, one post, one alliance—or one misstep—and your reputation may change. This doesn’t mean Ethos is flawed. Quite the opposite—it proves that Ethos is a valuable decentralized sentiment observatory. But we must understand: ✦ Consensus is fuzzy, not final ✦ Reputation is fluid, driven by events ✦ Being voted on ≠ being defined Final Words from Mao Mao Ethos gives us a first glimpse into two things: → Reputation is now visible → Consensus is now measurable But it also exposes an uncomfortable Web3 truth: Labels travel faster. Bias is exposed more vividly. Forgiveness is harder to come by. That’s not a bug—it’s the reality. Before diving into Web3, one must first accept: No reputation is immune to outside influence. No one escapes the pressure of collective perception. Serpin said something worth remembering: “We’re not forecasting who will be left in the cold—we’re simply recording how consensus is shifting.” 🔔 What's New in the Latest Ethos Update? Congrats if you’ve made it this far—this is the part you care about most. Let’s talk Season I. ✨ Ethos Season I Is Coming Keywords: Behavioral Signals, Reputation Assets, Contribution Quantification Ethos is entering a new, more systematic and traceable reputation era: Season I. This will be a deep experiment in how Web3 communities score consensus, map trust, and financialize identity. 🎯 1. Content Quality Every vouch, slash, or comment is scored based on quality. → High-quality input feeds directly into the reputation model. 🤝 2. Trust Support (Vouching) ETH you stake in support of someone becomes a public trust marker. → Mutual vouches are weighted more heavily. 💠 3. Holding Positions on http://Ethos.markets Your trust/distrust positions are seen as speculative consensus signals. → High-risk positions = higher signal value. 🎟️ 4. Validator NFTs Owning these adds extra weight to your actions. → Acts as identity verification and systemic trust signal. 🩸 5. Slash Participation Quality of participation matters more than quantity. → Sharp, well-reasoned slashes are valued. 📆 6. Daily Streaks Active daily check-ins build your Reputation Timeline. → Helps track your consistency. 📲 7. X Platform Validations Use @ethosAgent validate to verify real behavior on Twitter. → Bridge between Web2 behavior and Web3 identity. → Rankings live at: http://validate.ethos.network (Shoutout to @_MLO for sharing the English version of this feature!) 🆕 Newest Ethos Feature Updates (June 2025) 1️⃣ Local Sentiment Analysis Logged-in users now see consensus filtered through their trusted circles. → No longer relying on global averages. → See how people you follow, engage with, or vouch for perceive others. → A “trust filter” based on your social graph. Real Impact: Less vulnerable to manipulation by outsiders More accurate consensus reflection Ideal for DAOs, collective governance, and reputation management 2️⃣ Leaderboard + Identity Highlights Now you can see your exact rank and unique identity badges like: → “early slasher”, “top vouch node”, “validator”, “daily streak leader”, etc. This brings: Transparent identity feedback Foundation for your on-chain reputation profile Key tools for fair governance and rewards Just saw a message in the group—InfoFi leader @KaitoAI is about to join the reputation scoring race. The battle is officially on. Can @ethos_network hold its ground and ship something truly irreplaceable? We'll see. To be continued… #infofi #socialfi #attentionfi